How to Prepare for CADRES Mediation Without a Lawyer in Maine

If you're heading into mandatory CADRES mediation in Maine without an attorney, the single most important thing you can do is arrive with a written parenting plan proposal — not vague preferences, but specific schedules with overnight counts, holiday rotations, and decision-making provisions already drafted. Parents who show up with a structured proposal typically reach agreement faster and walk away with more of what they asked for than parents who try to build the plan from scratch during the session.

CADRES (Court Alternative Dispute Resolution Service) mediation is mandatory in all contested custody cases involving minor children in Maine, under Rule of Civil Procedure 92(b). The fee is $160 total ($80 per parent), and the session typically lasts 2 to 3 hours. The mediator helps you negotiate, but they don't draft your plan for you — if you arrive without preparation, you'll spend most of that time figuring out what you want rather than negotiating for it.

Step 1: Understand What the Mediator Expects

The CADRES mediator is not your attorney, your therapist, or your judge. They facilitate negotiation between two parents. They will not tell you what's "fair" or recommend a specific schedule. They will ask both parents what they propose and help identify compromises.

This means the burden of preparation falls entirely on you. The mediator expects you to arrive able to articulate:

• Which type of parental rights you're requesting (shared, allocated, or sole)
• A specific weekly parenting schedule with transition days and times
• How holidays, school breaks, and summer vacations will rotate
• Who will make major decisions about education, healthcare, and religion
• How you'll handle transportation between households
• What your child support calculation looks like under the Income Shares Model

Step 2: Draft Three Scenarios Before You Walk In

Experienced family law attorneys prepare their clients with multiple positions: optimal, acceptable, and compromise. You should do the same.

Scenario 1 — Optimal: Your preferred outcome if the other parent agrees to everything. Be specific: "Alternating weeks, Friday 5:00 PM to Friday 5:00 PM, with shared parental rights and responsibilities for all major decisions."

Scenario 2 — Acceptable: What you'd agree to without feeling you gave up too much. "2-2-5 rotation, shared rights for education and healthcare, allocated religion decisions to primary residential parent."

Scenario 3 — Compromise floor: The minimum you'd accept before walking out and letting the court decide. Know this number going in so you don't agree to something under pressure that you'll regret.

For each scenario, calculate the overnight count. This matters because Maine uses a threshold — typically around 30% of overnights — to determine whether a parent qualifies for the "substantially equal care" child support adjustment on Supplemental Worksheet FM-040-A.

Step 3: Run the Child Support Math First

One of the most common mistakes in CADRES mediation is negotiating a parenting schedule without understanding its child support implications. In Maine, the schedule is the child support calculation — more overnights shift the math significantly.

Before mediation, fill out the Child Support Affidavit (FM-050) with your actual income numbers and work through the Child Support Worksheet (FM-040) for each of your three scenarios. The difference between a 60/40 and 50/50 overnight split can mean hundreds of dollars per month.

Knowing these numbers in advance prevents two common traps: agreeing to a schedule that creates an unaffordable support obligation, or rejecting a schedule that would actually have given you more parenting time with a smaller financial impact than you assumed.

Step 4: Prepare Your Documentation

Bring these to the mediation session:

• Your three written scenarios — printed, not just in your head
• A filled-out child support worksheet for at least your primary scenario
• Your work schedule — including any rotating shifts, travel requirements, or seasonal variations
• Your child's school calendar — bell times, vacation dates, professional development days
• A proposed holiday rotation — odd/even year assignments for every major holiday plus school breaks
• Extracurricular schedules — sports, music, tutoring, therapy appointments
• Transportation logistics — driving times between households, proximity to school, who does pickup/dropoff
• Communication proposals — how parents will communicate (text, email, app), response time expectations

Step 5: Know What to Avoid

Don't argue the past. The mediator is forward-looking. Relitigating who did what during the marriage wastes your limited session time.

Don't use vague language. "Reasonable contact" is unenforceable in Maine. If mediation produces an agreement with ambiguous scheduling language, either parent can exploit it and the other has limited recourse. Specificity protects both sides.

Don't agree under pressure. If you're unsure about a provision, you can ask the mediator for a break. You can also end the session without an agreement — the case then proceeds to a contested hearing, which isn't ideal but is better than a bad agreement.

Don't bring up the other parent's character. Focus on logistics, scheduling, and the child's needs. Character attacks derail productive negotiation.

What Happens If Mediation Fails

If you don't reach agreement in CADRES, the case returns to the District Court docket for a contested hearing before a family law magistrate. The magistrate will apply the best-interest factors under Title 19-A § 1653(3), hear testimony from both parents (and possibly a Guardian ad Litem), and issue a binding order. This process takes longer, costs more, and gives you less control over the outcome.

Most mediators report that parents who arrive prepared reach full or partial agreement in their first session. Preparation is the difference between a productive two-hour session and a wasted one.

Who This Is For

• Self-represented parents who want to prepare for CADRES mediation thoroughly, not just show up and see what happens
• Parents who can communicate with their co-parent but disagree on scheduling specifics
• Anyone who wants to understand how their proposed schedule affects child support before negotiating

Who This Is NOT For

• Parents with active domestic violence concerns — if you have a protection order, you may be exempt from in-person mediation or may request separate sessions
• Parents who have already retained an attorney — your lawyer will prepare you
• Cases where the other parent refuses to engage in good-faith negotiation

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I bring notes or documents into the mediation room?

Yes. Bring everything you've prepared — printed schedules, child support calculations, holiday proposals. Mediators expect and encourage preparation. Having your numbers and proposals on paper keeps the conversation focused and productive.

What if the other parent brings a lawyer and I don't have one?

Each parent may bring an attorney to CADRES mediation, but it's not required and many parents attend without counsel. If the other parent has an attorney, consider requesting at least one hour of "unbundled" legal coaching ($200–$350) before the session to review your proposals and identify any provisions you might be overlooking.

Does the mediator's recommendation carry weight with the judge?

CADRES mediation is confidential. The mediator does not report what was discussed or recommend outcomes to the court. They report only whether an agreement was reached, reached in part, or not reached. Your positions in mediation cannot be used against you later.

How long does a CADRES session last?

Typically 2 to 3 hours. If you're well-prepared with written proposals, you'll use that time negotiating rather than organizing your thoughts — which is why the parents who walk in with structured plans consistently get better outcomes.

The Maine Child Custody & Parenting Plan Guide includes a complete CADRES mediation preparation worksheet with space for all three scenarios, child support pre-calculations, and a checklist of documents to bring — everything covered in this article, structured as a printable workbook you can fill in with your actual numbers.

See more Maine guides →