How to Prepare for Delaware Custody Mediation Without an Attorney

Mandatory mediation is where most Delaware custody cases are decided. If you and your co-parent reach an agreement during mediation, it becomes a Consent Order (Form 349) — a binding court order signed by a judge, without either of you ever setting foot in a hearing. If mediation fails, your case goes to a bench trial, which costs significantly more time, money, and emotional energy.

Preparation is the difference between walking out with a signed agreement and walking into months of contested litigation. Here is exactly how to prepare for Delaware Family Court mediation without an attorney.

Step 1: Complete Your Form 364 Before the Session

The Custody, Visitation, and Guardianship Disclosure Report (Form 364) is the mandatory document you must bring to mediation. It requires you to outline:

• Your proposed custody arrangement (joint or sole legal custody, physical placement)
• Your desired parenting schedule (specific days, overnights, and transition times)
• Your daily caregiving routines (who handles school drop-off, meals, bedtime, homework)
• Safety concerns (domestic violence, substance abuse, mental health issues affecting the child)
• Your child's special needs (medical conditions, therapies, educational accommodations)

The form itself is straightforward — the challenge is filling it out strategically. Every answer you provide becomes a starting point for negotiation. Vague answers ("we will work it out") give the mediator nothing to work with. Specific, organized proposals ("Parent A has the child Monday through Wednesday; Parent B has Thursday through Saturday; Sunday alternates biweekly") give the mediator a concrete framework.

Key preparation step: Draft your proposed parenting schedule on a physical calendar first. Count the annual overnights for each parent. Under Delaware's Melson Formula, the overnight count directly controls child support: 0–79 overnights = 0% credit, 80–124 = 10% credit, 125–163 = 30% credit, 164+ = shared placement formula. Know where your proposal falls before you walk into mediation.

Step 2: Organize Your Best-Interest Arguments

The mediator's job is to help you reach an agreement — not to decide your case. But every proposal you make will be evaluated through the lens of 13 Del. C. § 722, Delaware's best-interest standard. Organizing your position around these statutory factors makes your proposals more persuasive and shows the mediator you are serious.

For each factor, prepare a brief written summary:

• Your involvement in the child's daily life — school, medical appointments, extracurricular activities, homework
• Your home environment — stability, safety, proximity to the child's school and community
• The child's relationships — with both parents, siblings, grandparents, and other significant people
• Communication with the other parent — evidence of your efforts to cooperate and co-parent
• Compliance with parenting responsibilities — your track record of meeting the child's needs

You do not need to present this to the mediator as a formal document. Having it organized in your own notes ensures you can articulate your position clearly when the mediator asks specific questions.

Step 3: Prepare Your Non-Negotiables and Flexibility Points

Before mediation, divide your priorities into three categories:

Non-negotiable (absolute requirements):

• Safety provisions you will not compromise on
• Access to school and medical decision-making
• Minimum parenting time thresholds

Important but flexible (preferred but open to alternatives):

• Specific weekday arrangements
• Holiday rotation preferences
• Transportation logistics

Tradeable (willing to concede for something more important):

• Minor scheduling details
• Which parent claims the child as a tax dependent in specific years
• Pickup and drop-off timing adjustments

Walking in with this mental framework prevents you from fighting equally hard on every point — a pattern that signals to the mediator you are not genuinely negotiating and pushes your case toward a hearing.

Step 4: Prepare Specific Schedule Proposals

Do not arrive with a single "my way or nothing" proposal. Prepare two or three schedule options that each serve the child's interests but differ in structure:

Option A: Your preferred arrangement (the proposal you submit on Form 364)

Option B: A modification that addresses a likely objection from the other parent — perhaps adjusting the midweek overnight or changing the holiday rotation

Option C: A minimum-acceptable arrangement that protects your core priorities while making meaningful concessions

Having alternatives ready shows the mediator you are acting in good faith and makes productive negotiation possible.

Step 5: Know What Happens If Mediation Fails

If you and your co-parent cannot reach an agreement, the mediator may recommend an Interim Order — a temporary parenting schedule that stays in place until your case is resolved at trial. Understanding this possibility helps you negotiate more effectively, because the alternative to reaching an agreement today is not "nothing changes" — it is a schedule the mediator recommends to the judge based on their assessment of both parents' positions.

After failed mediation, the timeline looks like this:

1. Case assigned to a Family Court Judge
2. Case Management Conference within approximately 30 days
3. Discovery phase (financial disclosures, Form 16A, evidence exchange)
4. Bench trial where both parents present evidence under the Delaware Rules of Evidence

Most contested custody cases take 6–12 months from filing to final order. Reaching an agreement at mediation compresses that timeline to weeks.

Common Mediation Mistakes to Avoid

Arriving unprepared. An incomplete Form 364 and vague proposals waste the mediation session and signal to the mediator that you are not taking the process seriously.

Making it about the other parent. Mediation is forward-looking. The mediator does not want to hear a list of grievances about your co-parent's past behavior (unless it is a safety concern). Focus on what schedule and terms best serve the child going forward.

Refusing to compromise on anything. If you treat every point as non-negotiable, the mediator will conclude that mediation is not viable and refer your case to a judge — who will then make all of these decisions for you.

Ignoring the child support implications. Your proposed schedule determines your child support obligation. Parents who agree to a schedule without understanding the Melson Formula's overnight thresholds sometimes discover later that their agreement costs them hundreds of dollars more per month than they expected.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to attend mediation in Delaware?

Yes. Mandatory mediation is required for almost all contested custody cases. The only exceptions are cases involving an active Protection from Abuse (PFA) order, an adjudicated history of domestic violence, or a party who is a registered sex offender. Even with an attorney, you attend mediation personally.

Can I bring someone to mediation with me?

You can bring an attorney if you have one — they can attend and advise you during the session. You generally cannot bring family members, friends, or other support people into the mediation room. If you have a domestic violence history and mediation is proceeding with your attorney's consent, your attorney must be physically present.

What if my co-parent refuses to negotiate at mediation?

If one parent refuses to engage meaningfully, the mediator will note this and the case proceeds to a judicial hearing. The judge will be aware that mediation was attempted. A parent who clearly refused to negotiate in good faith may face an adverse inference when the judge evaluates the best-interest factor of willingness to foster the child's relationship with the other parent.

The Delaware Child Custody & Parenting Plan Guide includes a complete Form 364 preparation walkthrough, overnight calculation worksheets, and parenting schedule templates mapped to the Melson Formula's credit thresholds — everything you need to walk into mediation with organized, enforceable proposals.

See more Delaware guides →