Parenting Plan Guide vs Free Cafcass 'Our Child's Plan' Template: What's the Difference?

The free Cafcass Cymru "Our Child's Plan" template is a solid starting framework — it covers the core headings every parenting plan needs and it's officially endorsed. But it's a template, not a guide. It gives you boxes to fill in without telling you what to write in them, how to structure a schedule that satisfies the welfare checklist, or how your proposed overnight counts affect your Child Maintenance Service liability. If you already know what you're doing, the template is enough. If you're working out child arrangements for the first time, it's a blank canvas when you need a paint-by-numbers.

What Each One Actually Contains

Where the Free Template Falls Short

The "Our Child's Plan" template asks you to describe your child's routine, living arrangements, and how you'll handle disagreements. These are the right questions. The problem is that answering them well requires knowledge the template doesn't provide.

Schedule design without context. The template asks "Where will our child live?" but doesn't explain the difference between alternating weekends, 2-2-3 rotations, 2-2-5-5 splits, or week-on/week-off arrangements. It doesn't tell you which patterns work better for different age groups, which ones cross the 52-night CMS threshold, or which are easier for Welsh family courts to enforce.

No connection to CMS overnight bands. The Child Maintenance Service uses five overnight bands to calculate shared care reductions: under 52 nights (no reduction), 52–103 nights (one-seventh), 104–155 nights (two-sevenths), 156–174 nights (three-sevenths), and 175+ nights (equal care). Your schedule design directly determines which band you fall into — a difference of thousands of pounds per year. The free template doesn't mention this connection at all.

No court preparation. The template helps you document an agreement. It doesn't prepare you for the process of reaching one. If you're heading into mediation, a Cafcass Cymru safeguarding call, or a court hearing, the template gives you something to write on but nothing to say.

No welfare checklist alignment. Every judicial decision about children in England and Wales must consider the seven factors in Section 1(3) of the Children Act 1989: the child's wishes, physical and emotional needs, likely effect of change, age and background, any harm suffered or at risk, parental capability, and the range of powers available to the court. A parenting plan that explicitly addresses these factors is taken more seriously than one that doesn't. The free template doesn't reference the welfare checklist or show you how to frame your proposals around it.

When the Free Template Is Enough

The Cafcass "Our Child's Plan" template works well if:

• Both parents have already agreed on the major points and just need to write it down
• You've been through the custody process before and understand how Welsh family courts work
• You're using it alongside professional mediation where the mediator guides the conversation
• Your arrangement is straightforward — one primary residence, regular contact weekends, standard holiday splits

In these situations, the template serves its purpose as a documentation tool. You don't need a guide to tell you what to write because you already know.

When You Need More Than the Template

A process guide adds value when:

• You're separating for the first time and don't understand the difference between a Child Arrangements Order, Parental Responsibility, and a Consent Order
• You're self-representing and need to file a C100 application — the template doesn't cover the form, the fee, or the supporting documents
• You're preparing for the Cafcass Cymru safeguarding call and want to know what the Family Proceedings Officer is actually assessing
• Your proposed schedule has financial implications — you need to understand where it falls in the CMS overnight bands before committing to terms
• The other parent disagrees on arrangements and you need to present a structured, welfare-checklist-aligned proposal that a court can take seriously
• You're an unmarried father who needs to secure Parental Responsibility before addressing contact arrangements

The Practical Gap

Think of it this way: the free template is like a blank recipe card. A process guide is like a cookbook that also explains how to use the recipe card. If you've cooked this dish before, the blank card is fine. If it's your first time and the stakes are high — which they are when your children's living arrangements depend on what you write — the cookbook gives you the context that the blank card assumes you already have.

The financial comparison reinforces this. A single mediation session costs £120–£138. A family solicitor charges £150–£500 per hour. A fixed-fee document service charges around £240 just to fill in the C100 form. A process guide costs a fraction of any of these, and if it helps you arrive at mediation with schedule drafts already prepared — or file a complete C100 application without needing a document service — it pays for itself immediately.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Cafcass "Our Child's Plan" legally binding?

No. A parenting plan — whether created using the Cafcass template or any other format — is a voluntary agreement. To make it legally binding, you need to convert it into a Consent Order approved by the court (fee: £60, rising to £62 from July 2026). The template helps you document what you've agreed. The court process makes it enforceable.

Can I use both together?

Yes. Use a process guide to understand the system, work out your schedule options, and prepare for Cafcass Cymru. Then use "Our Child's Plan" as the final documentation format if that's what your mediator or the court prefers. The guide gives you the thinking; the template gives you the structure to present it.

Will the court reject a parenting plan that doesn't use the Cafcass template?

No. Courts care about the content of your parenting plan, not the format. A plan that addresses the welfare checklist, specifies clear schedules, and accounts for holidays and handovers will be taken seriously regardless of whether it uses the Cafcass headings. The Wales Child Custody & Parenting Plan Guide produces a plan that covers everything the court expects — and more than the free template addresses.

My mediator suggested using "Our Child's Plan" — should I still get a guide?

Using the mediator's preferred template for the final document makes sense. But arriving at mediation having already worked through a guide means you'll have concrete proposals ready — specific days, overnight counts, holiday rotations — instead of starting the session from scratch. Mediators charge by the hour. Walking in prepared saves time and money.

See more Wales guides →