How Debt Is Divided in Massachusetts Divorce

Debt division in Massachusetts follows the same equitable distribution rules as asset division — the court weighs the Section 34 factors and assigns liabilities based on fairness, not a 50/50 split. But there's a critical difference between how the court allocates debt and how creditors view it, and that gap is where people get hurt.

The Creditor Problem

A divorce judgment can assign a joint credit card balance to your ex-spouse. But the credit card company isn't bound by your divorce agreement. If both names are on the account, the creditor can still come after either person for the full balance.

This creates a specific scenario that catches people off guard: the court assigns the $18,000 joint Visa balance to your ex. Your ex stops making payments six months later. The creditor reports the default on both credit scores and sues both account holders. You're stuck explaining to a judge why you shouldn't pay a debt the divorce court told your ex to handle.

The divorce court can hold your ex in contempt for violating the separation agreement, but that doesn't repair your credit or stop the collection calls.

How to Protect Yourself

Close Joint Accounts

The most effective protection is eliminating joint liability entirely. Before or immediately after the divorce, close every joint credit card, HELOC, and line of credit. If a balance exists, one option is for each spouse to transfer their assigned portion to individual accounts.

Require Refinancing on a Timeline

For secured debts like mortgages and auto loans, the separation agreement should require the retaining spouse to refinance into their name alone within a specific timeframe — typically 90 to 180 days. If they can't qualify for refinancing, the asset should be sold to eliminate the joint debt.

Include Indemnification Clauses

A hold-harmless and indemnification clause states that the spouse who was assigned the debt will "hold harmless" the other spouse from any claims, fees, or damages if they fail to pay. This doesn't prevent the creditor from pursuing you, but it gives you legal recourse against your ex — including the right to recover attorney fees and any amounts you were forced to pay.

A strong indemnification clause covers:

• The principal balance
• Interest and late fees
• Collection costs
• Attorney fees incurred to enforce the clause
• Credit repair costs

How Courts Decide Who Gets What Debt

Under Section 34, the court considers the same factors for debt allocation as for asset division:

Who incurred the debt? A credit card in one spouse's name, used for their personal expenses, is more likely to be assigned to them. Joint debts used for family expenses are more likely to be divided.

Who has the ability to pay? The higher-earning spouse may be assigned a larger share of joint debt, particularly if the other spouse has limited income or employment prospects.

Was the debt marital or premarital? A student loan one spouse brought into the marriage is more likely to remain with that spouse, especially in a shorter marriage. However, if the degree earned from that student loan significantly boosted the family's income, the court may consider it a marital investment.

Was the debt incurred in bad faith? Under Supplemental Rule 411, the automatic restraining order takes effect against the plaintiff when the complaint is filed and against the defendant when the defendant is served. It prohibits either spouse from incurring new debts that would burden the other's credit. Debts incurred in violation of this order are likely to be assigned entirely to the violating spouse.

Student Loans

Student loan debt allocation depends on context:

• Premarital student loans generally stay with the borrower, especially in shorter marriages.
• Student loans incurred during the marriage are assessed based on whether the education benefited the marital unit. A degree that doubled one spouse's earning capacity represents a marital investment — the court may offset this by awarding the non-student spouse more assets or assigning more of the general debt to the student spouse.
• Federal vs. private doesn't change the allocation analysis, but it matters for repayment: federal loans offer income-driven repayment plans that can help the assigned spouse manage payments.

Credit Card Debt

Credit cards are the most common source of debt disputes. Key considerations:

• Individual cards used for personal spending are typically assigned to the cardholder.
• Joint cards used for household expenses are generally divided based on ability to pay.
• Hidden spending — if one spouse ran up $15,000 on a credit card without the other's knowledge, particularly after the automatic restraining order took effect, the court will likely assign that debt solely to the spender.

The practical challenge is proving who spent what. Credit-card statements, together with the Rule 410 financial disclosures, provide the evidence. Categorize spending by purpose: household expenses, personal purchases, business expenses, and cash advances.

Tax Debt and Joint Returns

If you filed joint tax returns during the marriage — or during the nisi period, when you're still legally married — both spouses share joint and several liability for any underpayment, interest, or penalties. The divorce agreement can assign tax liability to one spouse, but the IRS and Massachusetts Department of Revenue can still pursue either person.

If you suspect your spouse underreported income or took fraudulent deductions, explore Innocent Spouse Relief with the IRS before the divorce finalizes. The window for filing is limited, and the relief is not automatic.

Our Massachusetts Financial Split Guide includes a debt allocation worksheet that helps you categorize every liability, identify joint vs. individual accounts, and draft indemnification language for your separation agreement.

The Bottom Line

The court divides debt equitably, but creditors honor contracts, not divorce agreements. Close joint accounts, require refinancing on a deadline, and insist on strong indemnification clauses. The goal isn't just getting the court to assign debt to your ex — it's actually removing your name from the liability.

See more Massachusetts guides →