What Happens at a PA Custody Conciliation Conference
Mediation didn't resolve everything, and now you've got a date for a custody conciliation conference. This is where most Pennsylvania custody cases actually get decided — not at trial. The conciliation conference is the point where a court-appointed officer evaluates both parents' positions and issues a recommended custody order. What happens in this meeting carries real weight, and most parents underestimate how much preparation it demands.
Who Runs the Conference
The conciliation conference is presided over by a court-appointed Custody Master or Hearing Officer — often called a conference officer or conciliator depending on the county. The exact role and procedure vary by county. They've read your file before you walk in, including the custody complaint, any existing orders, and whatever documentation has been submitted.
The conference officer isn't a mediator. Unlike mediation, where the neutral party facilitates conversation but makes no decisions, the conference officer actively evaluates your case. They'll ask questions, probe inconsistencies, and form an opinion about what custody arrangement serves the child's best interests. In some counties, the officer may even request a voluntary urine drug analysis on-site if substance abuse concerns have been raised.
The Format
Conciliation conferences are structured, non-record office conferences. "Non-record" means there's no court reporter transcribing the proceedings, and the conference is not a formal evidentiary hearing. Attorneys are present (if you have them), but the atmosphere is more like a structured negotiation than a courtroom hearing.
The typical flow:
- Opening review — the officer summarizes the case history and identifies the specific custody issues in dispute
- Each parent's position — you present what custody arrangement you're seeking and why it serves the child's interests
- Questions from the officer — expect pointed questions about your daily routine, the child's school performance, your work schedule, and your relationship with the co-parent
- Negotiation — the officer may shuttle between the parties, suggest compromises, and pressure test each parent's position
- Outcome — either an agreement or a recommended order
The Recommended Order
If parents reach an agreement during the conference, the officer drafts a consent order reflecting those terms. Both parents sign, and it goes to a judge for approval.
If you don't agree, the conference officer issues a recommended interim custody order based on their assessment. This is where the real consequence sits: in many Pennsylvania counties, the recommended order automatically becomes a final, appealable order within a specified timeframe unless one party files a formal demand for trial.
In Chester County, for example, that window is 180 days. If neither parent demands a trial within that period, the conference officer's recommendation becomes a final, appealable custody order under the county's procedure. Other counties have different timeframes, but the mechanism is the same.
That means the conciliation conference isn't just a step in the process. For the majority of cases, it's the decision point.
Free Download
Get the Pennsylvania — Parenting Plan Starter Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
How to Prepare
Conference officers make assessments quickly. You have a limited window to present your case, and the officer is weighing your credibility, reasonableness, and focus on the child's welfare from the moment you start talking. Preparation matters more here than at almost any other stage.
Document your daily routine. The officer will ask who handles morning routines, school pickup, homework, bedtime, and medical appointments. Vague answers ("I do everything") carry less weight than specific, verifiable details. If you coach soccer practice on Wednesdays and handle all dental appointments, say exactly that.
Know the twelve best-interest factors. Under Act 11 of 2025, Pennsylvania courts evaluate custody using twelve consolidated factors (23 Pa.C.S. § 5328(a)). The conference officer is mentally running through these factors while you talk. If you can address how your proposed schedule serves each relevant factor — especially the safety factors that carry "substantial weighted consideration" under Kayden's Law — you'll make a stronger impression.
Bring a written schedule proposal. Don't walk in with a vague idea. Bring a specific, day-by-day parenting plan that accounts for school weeks, weekends, holidays, and summer. Officers respond well to parents who've done the work of thinking through logistics rather than expecting the court to design a schedule for them.
Stay child-focused. Conference officers hear complaints about co-parents all day. What they're listening for is which parent focuses on the child's needs versus which parent focuses on the other parent's failings. Frame every position around your child's routine, stability, and relationships — not your grievances.
Don't refuse reasonable compromises. The conference officer is assessing your willingness to cooperate (Factor 4 under Act 11 — co-parenting and cooperation). A parent who rejects every proposed compromise may get a less favorable recommended order, because the officer reads inflexibility as a predictor of future conflict.
What Not to Do
Don't bring witnesses — the conciliation conference doesn't take testimony. Don't bring your new partner unless specifically instructed. Don't interrupt your co-parent when they're speaking. And don't make threats about what you'll do if the conference doesn't go your way.
The officer's recommended order reflects their professional assessment after hearing both sides. Emotional outbursts, personal attacks on your co-parent, or obvious coaching of your narrative will work against you.
After the Conference
If you receive a recommended order you can live with, you can let the automatic-entry period run and it becomes final. If the recommendation is genuinely unworkable — not just imperfect, but substantively problematic — you can file a demand for trial before a Court of Common Pleas judge. That trial is a full evidentiary hearing with testimony, cross-examination, and a formal record.
Keep in mind that demanding trial resets the process and can add months of litigation. Most attorneys advise demanding trial only when the recommended order contains a significant factual error or misapplies the custody factors.
The Pennsylvania Child Custody & Parenting Plan Guide includes a conference preparation worksheet that walks you through each best-interest factor with space to document your evidence and draft your proposed schedule before you sit down with the officer.
Get Your Free Pennsylvania — Parenting Plan Starter Checklist
Download the Pennsylvania — Parenting Plan Starter Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.