Can a Child Choose Which Parent to Live With in PEI?

This is one of the most Googled custody questions in PEI, and the answer consistently surprises parents: there is no age at which a child gets to decide. Not 12, not 14, not 16. PEI law does not set a threshold birthday after which the child's preference becomes binding. The child's views are always one factor among many — never the only one.

What the Law Actually Says

Both the Divorce Act and PEI's Children's Law Act require the court to consider the child's views and preferences as part of the best-interests-of-the-child analysis. But the weight given to those views depends on the child's age, maturity, and developmental capacity — not a fixed number.

A thoughtful, articulate thirteen-year-old who can explain why they prefer one arrangement over another will carry more weight than an eight-year-old who is repeating something a parent said during an argument. But even a mature teenager's strong preference does not override the court's obligation to consider safety, stability, existing relationships, and the other statutory factors.

How Courts Hear the Child's Voice

PEI courts can gather a child's views through specialized mechanisms, including:

Views of the Child reports. A trained professional (usually through the Family Court Conciliation Office) meets with the child in a neutral setting and prepares a written report summarizing the child's expressed views and preferences. The report captures what the child said without interpretation or recommendation. Parents do not attend these interviews. The report goes to the judge, and both parents receive copies.

Parenting Arrangement Assessments. In more complex or contested cases, the court may order a full clinical assessment conducted by a Family Court Clinician. This is more comprehensive than a Views of the Child report — it involves interviews with both parents, interviews with the child, home visits, and collateral contacts (teachers, doctors, therapists, and other relevant sources). The clinician produces a detailed report with recommendations about parenting arrangements. These assessments can take three to six months to complete.

Why a Child's Preference Is Not Determinative

Courts weigh a child's stated preference against context. A child who says they want to live with one parent because that parent has fewer rules and no bedtime is expressing a preference — but it does not serve the child's best interests. A child who prefers one parent because they feel unsafe with the other is expressing something the court takes very seriously.

Judges also watch for signs that a child's views have been influenced by a parent — coaching, alienation, or exposure to adult conflict that has shaped the child's loyalty. If the court suspects a child's stated preference is not genuinely their own, it will discount it.

What This Means for Parents

If your child has expressed a preference about where they want to live, do not assume the court will simply follow it. And if your child has not expressed a preference, do not try to extract one — involving children in loyalty conflicts causes real harm and will work against you in court.

The most productive approach: build a parenting proposal that serves the child's stability, safety, and relationships, and let the professionals handle gathering the child's views through the proper channels.

The Prince Edward Island Child Custody & Parenting Plan Guide explains how the child's voice fits into the broader best-interests framework and how to structure your proposal accordingly.

See more Prince Edward Island guides →