How to Prepare for a Custody Hearing in Tennessee

If mediation didn't resolve your custody dispute, you're headed to trial. A Tennessee custody hearing is where a judge evaluates both parents against the 15 statutory best-interest factors and enters a final Permanent Parenting Plan. How you prepare directly affects the outcome.

What to Expect at the Hearing

A custody trial in Tennessee takes place in Circuit Court or Chancery Court before a judge — there's no jury in custody cases. Both parents (or their attorneys) present evidence, call witnesses, and make arguments about what parenting arrangement serves the child's best interests.

The hearing can last anywhere from a few hours for straightforward cases to multiple days for complex, high-conflict disputes. Each parent has the opportunity to present their proposed parenting plan and explain why their arrangement is better for the child.

Evidence That Matters

Judges make decisions based on evidence, not emotional appeals. Focus your preparation on documentation that directly addresses the 15 best-interest factors:

Daily caregiving evidence:

• School attendance records showing which parent handles drop-off and pickup
• Medical and dental appointment records (who scheduled them, who attended)
• Extracurricular activity sign-ups and attendance logs
• Communication logs with teachers, coaches, and healthcare providers

Home stability evidence:

• Lease or mortgage documents showing your living situation
• Photos of the child's bedroom and living space
• Employment records demonstrating stable income
• Evidence of the child's ties to their school and community

Co-parenting behavior:

• Text messages and emails showing your communication with the other parent
• Evidence of facilitating (not blocking) the child's relationship with the other parent
• Documentation of compliance with temporary orders and existing agreements

Safety concerns (if applicable):

• Police reports
• DCS investigation records
• Medical records documenting injuries
• Protective order filings

Custody Evaluations (Rule 35)

When a parent's mental health, substance use, or overall fitness is in question, the court may order a custody evaluation under Rule 35 of the Tennessee Rules of Civil Procedure. A court-appointed psychologist or psychiatrist evaluates both parents and the children, conducting interviews, psychological testing, and home visits.

The evaluator's report and recommendations carry significant weight with the judge. If an evaluation is ordered in your case, cooperate fully — refusing to participate will hurt your position.

Guardian ad Litem (Rule 40A)

In high-conflict or complex cases, the judge may appoint a Guardian ad Litem (GAL) — a licensed attorney whose sole job is to investigate and advocate for the child's best interests.

The GAL will:

• Interview both parents, the child, teachers, and healthcare providers
• Review medical, school, and counseling records
• Observe each parent's home environment
• Present an independent report and recommendation to the court

GAL fees are treated as court costs, typically divided between parents based on relative income. If one parent's bad-faith behavior necessitated the appointment, the court may shift the full cost to that parent.

Judges appoint GALs sparingly — factors that trigger appointment include severe parental conflict, allegations of coaching or manipulation, safety concerns, and potential relocation.

Drug and Alcohol Testing

If substance abuse is alleged, the court can order drug testing for either or both parents. This may include:

• Urine screens (standard panel)
• Hair follicle testing (detects use over a longer period)
• Court-ordered substance abuse evaluations

A positive test result or refusal to test significantly impacts the custody determination. If substance abuse is confirmed, the court may order supervised parenting time, substance abuse treatment, or both as conditions for maintaining or regaining unsupervised access.

Courtroom Behavior

How you present yourself matters:

• Stay calm and factual. Emotional outbursts, eye-rolling, or aggressive behavior in court damages your credibility.
• Answer questions directly. Don't volunteer irrelevant information or use your testimony as an opportunity to attack the other parent.
• Dress professionally. Courts expect appropriate attire — business or business casual.
• Be on time. Arriving late signals disrespect for the process.
• Don't discuss the case on social media. Opposing counsel will search your accounts. Posts about partying, reckless behavior, or disparaging comments about the other parent become exhibits.

Witness Preparation

You can call witnesses who can speak to your parenting involvement and the child's wellbeing. Good witnesses include:

• Teachers or school administrators who can confirm your involvement
• Pediatricians or family doctors who know the child's medical history
• Coaches, tutors, or activity leaders who've observed your relationship with the child
• Family members or close friends (though judges give these witnesses less weight due to inherent bias)

Each witness should be prepared to testify about specific observations, not general opinions about who's the better parent.

The Proposed Parenting Plan Deadline

If mediation fails, each parent must file their own proposed Permanent Parenting Plan at least 45 days before the trial date. This is a hard deadline — failing to file a proposed plan risks the court adopting the other parent's plan by default.

The Tennessee Child Custody & Parenting Plan Guide includes a trial preparation checklist organized by the 15 best-interest factors, plus worksheets for building a proposed parenting plan that addresses each factor with specific evidence.

See more Tennessee guides →