Minnesota Custody Evaluation: What to Expect

If you and your co-parent cannot reach a custody agreement through mediation or Early Neutral Evaluation, the court may order a formal custody evaluation under Minn. Stat. Section 518.167. This is the most intensive step in a contested custody case — and often the most stressful, because the evaluator's recommendation carries significant weight with the judge.

Here is how the process works and what you can do to prepare.

What a Custody Evaluator Does

A custody evaluator is a mental health professional (psychologist, social worker, or licensed counselor) appointed by the court to investigate and make a recommendation about the custody arrangement that best serves the child's interests. The evaluator is not your advocate or your co-parent's advocate — they work for the court on behalf of the child.

The evaluation typically includes:

Individual parent interviews. Each parent meets privately with the evaluator for one to three hours. You will be asked about your relationship with the child, your parenting approach, your daily routine, your co-parenting communication, and your concerns about the other parent.

Home visits. The evaluator visits each parent's home to observe the living environment, the child's bedroom and personal space, and the parent-child interaction in a natural setting. They are looking at safety, cleanliness, age-appropriate toys and books, and whether the child appears comfortable.

Child interviews. Depending on the child's age and maturity, the evaluator may speak with the child privately. They are trained to assess genuine feelings without putting the child in the middle or asking them to choose between parents.

Collateral contacts. The evaluator contacts third parties who interact regularly with the child — teachers, pediatricians, therapists, coaches, daycare providers. These contacts provide an independent perspective on each parent's involvement and the child's behavior in different environments.

Psychological testing. Some evaluators administer standardized psychological tests (such as the MMPI-2 or the MCMI-IV) to assess each parent's personality traits, mental health status, and parenting capacity.

Document review. The evaluator reviews court filings, police reports, medical records, school records, and any documentation submitted by either parent.

Questions You Should Expect

Custody evaluators commonly ask:

• Describe your typical day with the child from morning to bedtime
• How do you handle discipline and behavioral issues?
• What is your relationship with the other parent like? How do you communicate?
• What are your concerns about the other parent's care of the child?
• How do you support the child's relationship with the other parent?
• What parenting schedule do you think is best for the child, and why?
• Has the child expressed any preferences about where they want to live?
• Are there any safety concerns (substance use, domestic violence, untreated mental health issues)?

What Evaluators Are Looking For

Beyond the specific answers to their questions, evaluators are observing:

Consistency. Does your account of events match what collateral contacts and records show? Exaggeration or fabrication destroys credibility.

Child focus. Are you talking about what is best for the child, or are you focused on winning against your co-parent? Parents who badmouth the other parent during the evaluation hurt their own case.

Flexibility. Can you acknowledge the other parent's strengths? A parent who insists the other parent has no redeeming qualities looks unreasonable.

Emotional regulation. Can you discuss difficult topics — including the other parent's behavior — without becoming hostile, defensive, or tearful to the point of being unable to communicate?

Honesty about imperfections. Every parent makes mistakes. Acknowledging a parenting misstep and explaining what you learned from it is far more credible than claiming you have never done anything wrong.

How Long It Takes

A full custody evaluation typically takes four to twelve weeks from start to finish. The evaluator then submits a written report to the court with their findings and recommendations. Both parents and their attorneys receive copies.

The report is not binding — the judge makes the final decision. But in practice, judges give custody evaluation reports substantial weight, and the recommendation is adopted in the majority of cases.

Guardian ad Litem vs. Custody Evaluator

The court may also appoint a Guardian ad Litem (GAL) under Minn. Stat. Section 518.165. A GAL advocates for the child's best interests throughout the case, while a custody evaluator conducts a point-in-time investigation and files a report. In cases involving severe criminal history (murder, kidnapping, domestic assault by strangulation), a GAL appointment is mandatory.

How to Prepare

The best preparation is not rehearsing answers — evaluators see through scripted responses. Instead, focus on being organized and genuine:

1. Document your daily caregiving involvement (school pickups, medical appointments, homework, meals)
2. Prepare your home so it is clean, safe, and clearly set up for a child
3. Be on time for every appointment
4. Answer questions honestly and stay focused on the child's needs
5. Do not coach the child on what to say

The Minnesota Child Custody and Parenting Plan Guide includes a Best Interests Evidence Organizer that helps you compile the documentation an evaluator will review — caregiving logs, school involvement records, and medical appointment histories organized by the 12 statutory factors.

See more Minnesota guides →