Right of First Refusal in Indiana Custody Arrangements

When you need a babysitter during your parenting time, should the other parent get first dibs? Indiana says yes — with conditions. The state's Parenting Time Guidelines include a provision formally called the "Opportunity for Additional Parenting Time," which functions as a right of first refusal for childcare.

Getting this provision right in your parenting plan prevents constant arguments about who watches the kids and when.

How Indiana's Opportunity for Additional Parenting Time Works

Under Section I(C)(3) of the Indiana Parenting Time Guidelines, when the parent who has the child during their scheduled time needs childcare from someone outside the household, they must first offer that time to the other parent. Only if the other parent declines or does not respond within a reasonable timeframe can the active parent arrange alternative care.

The key exception: the obligation is not triggered when the child is cared for by a "responsible household family member." This means a stepparent, live-in grandparent, or adult sibling who resides in the home can watch the child without notifying the other parent. Unmarried partners, roommates, or visiting relatives do not qualify — their involvement triggers the offer requirement.

What the Guidelines Leave Open

The default guidelines are deliberately vague on several practical details, which is why negotiating specifics in your parenting plan matters.

Duration threshold. The guidelines do not set a minimum number of hours before the offer obligation kicks in. Without a defined threshold, even a two-hour errand could technically require notice. Most family law practitioners recommend negotiating a specific minimum, such as four hours, to avoid constant logistical friction.

Response time. The guidelines call for a "reasonable" timeframe but do not define one. Building a concrete response window into your plan — such as two hours for same-day requests — eliminates ambiguity.

Distance considerations. The offer must be "practical," meaning the court accounts for how far apart the parents live. If one parent is 90 minutes away, offering them a four-hour childcare window during a work shift may not be practical.

Custody Exchange and Transportation Rules

Indiana's default guidelines assign transportation responsibility to the parent beginning their parenting time — meaning the receiving parent handles pickup. This applies to regular schedule transitions, holiday exchanges, and makeup time.

For your parenting plan, define:

• Exchange location — the child's school, a neutral public location, or a parent's residence
• Backup protocol — what happens if a parent is late (a 30-minute grace period is common)
• Third-party exchanges — whether a grandparent or stepparent can handle pickup and dropoff when the parent cannot

High-conflict situations may warrant supervised exchanges at a designated neutral site, such as a police station lobby or a family services center.

Putting It in Your Parenting Plan

Vague right-of-first-refusal clauses generate more post-decree motions than almost any other parenting plan provision. Spelling out the duration trigger, response deadline, and communication method (text, email, or co-parenting app) in your written agreement saves both parents from returning to court.

The Indiana Child Custody & Parenting Plan Guide includes a dedicated worksheet for drafting these clauses with fill-in-the-blank specifics, so your final plan is enforceable and leaves nothing to interpretation.

See more Indiana guides →